Paying for extra content in order to play Dungeons and Dragons has been a very divisive topic in the D&D community. One camp sits on the side of “What? No way I’m paying for that content, I already bought the books!”, while another says “Anything to make my life easier is good for me! Sign me up!”. Both points of view have their merits, and yes, it is completely easy to DM D&D without having to sign up for DDI, after all, 30-plus years of D&D have been played without an electronic aid. But you know what? I’m an unabashed fan of the system, what it promises in the future, and the way it’s made my life easier as a NewbieDM. I make no apologies for it either.
You hear that? That’s the sound of half my audience calling me a WOTC shill and leaving my site. To the other half of you, let me tell you how using DDI can be good for your game:
Dungeon & Dragon Magazines. The two magazines that are included in the subscription package have proven to be valuable game aids for my table. If there is anything you can take from these sources, is the fact that they can be mined like crazy for material for your games. Maybe you don’t want to run the adventure path in its entirity, but take a look at the Scales of War campaign in Dungeon Magazine anyway (i’m not running it, btw). I created a PDF of all the adventures in the path, up to the month of May, and it clocks in at over 529 pages. That, my friends, are a lot of encounters and maps. But there’s more. The Dragon Magazine articles detailing cities for example, are great places to just drop into your homebrew world. The monsters, magical items, npc ideas, all the articles are a treasure trove of material that keeps you from having to spend too much time on creating stuff, and rather spend it playing. Doesn’t that alone pay the price of admission?
The Compendium. This has been my favorite tool as a DM. Need an 8th level lurker to throw at the party in the Underdark? The Compendium with all of its filters, quickly finds an appropriate monster for me. Traps for the appropriate level? Treasure? All these things are in the compendium. Sometimes the thing goes all haywire on me and searches don’t come through or I have to restart it, but on the whole, it’s been my favorite part of the experience. The only reason I’ve had to open a monster manual is for the fluff of a monster, in case I don’t know it. And here’s a tip I learned from the guys at Critical Hits, if you use the Compendium, along with Google Chrome, and Google Documents, your life becomes even easier. Copy the stat block on Chrome, paste it over to a Google Document, you can even edit it to level up or down the monster and voila! a nicely edited & updated stat block. I take screen sshots of the stat block, then paste it unto photoshop, and create monster jpegs. I have a small library of monster stats on jpeg that I just then drop unto my word documents if I want to reuse them. It doesn’t get easier for me.
Character Builder. The crown jewel of the system, so far… It is a great way to make characters using every single thing that has been published for PC’s. Including of course, every alternate option in Dragon Magazine and exclusive PHB3 content that’s available now. But you already knew that. Making a D&D character has never been easier. I made some characters on PCGEN for 3.5 and I prefer this program.
The future. Okay, so let’s talk the future, and some of WOTC’s stumbles getting to that future, because the naysayers will bring it up with some reason. In 2007 WOTC promised the world in regards to DDI, and they failed to deliver. And it left a bad taste in people’s mouths. They promised a digital game table, a character visualizer and other things. I argue that DDI doesn’t need any of that stuff, not now, and not ever. The Digital Game Table is available already via a variety of web sites. The Maptools and other like softewares of the world have that niche covered. Those software packages do the same thing WOTC promised, and for free. A character visualizer? Please, a good Google images search will give me the perfect dwarf I need. There’s no need to pay for that. What they can’t offer you on other sites is stuff like the upcoming monster builder. Allowing DM’s to build monsters and to mix and match powers from existing monsters, the Monster Builder looks to be the DM’s equivalent of the Character Builder.
Is DDI a little pricey? Well, my group was told that since they’d all benefit from it, each one had to pay their share. So no, it’s not too pricey for my group. They all use the character builder and benefit from my access to the compendium, magazines and other stuff, so they feel the small cost is justified.
In closing, I can strongly recommend a DDI subscription. This is especially true if you are a DM with not too much time on your hands to prepare and invent things. By the way, I wasn’t given a free subscription to plug this or review it either, I’m just telling you what works for me.
Todd
July 16, 2009
Pretty much the only thing I disagree with here is the Character Visualizer not being a big deal. Google Images is great for finding dwarves, yeah, but I’ve been looking for a decent portrait for my razorclaw shifter monk for weeks and have come up empty. I can totally see him in my head, but I can’t draw for beans. The Visualizer would help me out immensely. But I totally agree on all the rest. The Builder has taken character creation, for me, from “necessary but tedious component of playing the game” to a superfun exercise in experimentation without having to recalculate bonuses every time I add a feat or swap out an item.
dysonlogos
July 16, 2009
I just wish the Character Builder was multi-platform. I’m not willing to pay $200+ for a character generator which seems to be the item that most people love most about DDI.
Todd
July 16, 2009
Very true. I’m a Mac user myself. Ended up just looking for the cheapest copy of XP I could find and installing it via Boot Camp. In a perfect world there’d be a Mac-native version, but it doesn’t seem to be in the cards.
newbiedm
July 16, 2009
I should have mentioned about the lack of Mac support. It is a negative thing, although I have my suspisions that if subscriptions are high enough, and DDI is a success, a Mac version will be coming in the future.
Wyatt
July 16, 2009
DDI really has nothing which interests me or seems like it would make my life easy, given that while I would buy it just for Dungeon and Dragon, Dragon is taking extra special steps lately to ensure I don’t ever want to buy it (I’m actually not talking about the Revenant, seriously). But having said that, I can get Dragon and Dungeon from anyone in my posse, so I’m not about to pay for them.
That and I’m a huge homebrewer and the Character Builder’s mission appear to be to make you feel as bad as possible about that, from what I’ve seen. I’m too OCD so all my gaming material has to be text, text which I can manipulate and mess around with on the spot.
newbiedm
July 16, 2009
@Wyatt: when you get to my age, married and with kids, and you will 🙂 you’ll find that time will be a true nemesis against your gaming lifestyle. DDI keeps me from having to do the things that you so enjoy, so granted, it’s not for everyone, no. But it is for me.
Wyatt
July 16, 2009
Oh you. Wyatt, marriage and kids? You rascal you.
dysonlogos
July 16, 2009
With the program being built on the .net structure, I doubt we’ll see it being ported to Mac or Linux anytime soon, no matter how many people subscribe.
Wyatt
July 16, 2009
There are things like Mono being developed which make it sort of possible to use .Net stuff on Mac/Linux. I say sort of because every time I try it fails. But other people, reportedly, have gotten it to work. So if you like playing with the witch’s brew of open-source package-install stuffies, it may work for you. If it feels like it.
Gary Jackson
July 17, 2009
The compendium rocks. I can either spend twenty minutes sorting through a dozen or more books looking for something, or I can spend fifteen seconds on the compendium looking for it. I only wish they had more categories: templates and things like companions and familiars.
@Wyatt, re: Mono
The cake is a lie.
Doug Daulton
July 17, 2009
I am a big fan of DDI. My only complaint is that they should include legacy content as well.
Nibelung
July 17, 2009
Only to give an extra pov to you all, I’m brazilian, and very happy with my DDI subscription. Why? Let me give you a hint: Monster Manual 1 will be released here now, July 26. Player’s Handbook got released on the same event you guys get MM2 (good thing: errata included). And we have no idea when we will get all the other books, except DMG (August).
Amazon is a nice place to buy books too, but except if I want to pay 15 bucks per book, plus 30 buck of shipping, my book will arrive one month after it’s release. I still buy some crucial books I like to read (Eberron and adventures), but most crunch-heavy books, like the powers, I stay with my DDI acess and be happy about it.
So, to me, DDI isn’t only “magazines, official wiki and explendid builder”, but too “early acess to D&D books that would take a lot of time to get an eye over it, or that i need to buy before even see what would be inside it”.
Sean Brady
July 17, 2009
I agree totally on the value of DDI. I am in a similar situation to NewbieDM in that a) I am a newbie and b) I have no time to prep much less play games with work and kids. Characters builder is just an awesome way to play around with character builds. I recently built a Half Orc Beastmaster Ranger and was kinda eh about him until I played around with adding some Druid to him and now he has become my favorite character. I just would never have time to do that kind of playing w/o the character builder.
Compendium is open anytime I play (but I tend to flip through books for many things still – I bought them after all). I mess around with encounter builds in the encounter builder to get a rough idea of how powerful a group of monsters is, and if I am building from all standard monsters I copy the encounter direct from the builder.
Suffice it to say, I am a big fan.
Mike
July 17, 2009
I’d have to agree with NewbiDM here, the way me and my players look at it is that we’ve saved money. There is at least one new book that comes out a month at $40, we now have the benefit of said book without having to buy it. roughly $100 for a year. the compendium has been invaluable to all my games. the character builder is great for players. the new tools coming out look to help DM’s run the game even smother.
If you buy 1 book a month from WotC its worth it to change your buying habits and go digital. Sure its not the same thing but there comes a point in your life were your just tired of the same thing.
Peter
July 17, 2009
As a new DM I LOVE the Compendium. Any downtime at work and I can look up possible threats for my next encounter. They even have all the monsters from the RPGA modules (which are usually just regular monsters with alternate levels or flavors).
The encounter builder needs a bit of work, but that is also a nice feature to help keep things organized.
Will
July 17, 2009
D&DI seems like a fine concept, but I dislike the PC-only aspects of it. Of course, my games haven’t been running 4E, so it is much less useful in that respect.
Noumenon
July 17, 2009
Todd, regarding your razorclaw shifter monk, have you considered getting a picture drawn by AvatarArt?
Todd
July 18, 2009
I have thought about it actually. Just bought a friend an AvatarArt gift certificate for his birthday, so I know they do good work. It’s just that I’d want to go all out and I’m not up for dropping the money on another top-of-the-line portrait just yet.